Good point NSB. I've never considered myself attractive, nor have I ever thought I was ugly, I'm just average. If girls honestly went for true "insides" then I would be dating right now. I'm a kind, considerate, genuinely good person. Not clingy or stalker or anything. So, in my male opinion, I would say that girls go for more muscular, fit guys.

(This is all rooted in science though. Women go for the more attractive, physically fit men because instinctively they want stronger and healthier children. The reason men are more sexual and less picky about mates is because we want to spread our seed and keep the species alive and well.)